Customer Rating:  
Summary: Great set, sometimes poor sound quality
Comment: I'm a pretty big Merle Haggard fan (I got into him by purchasing the 5 new compilations of 10 of his early albums), and before I bought this highly-rated compilation I wondered how such a popular, apparently great album could be so cheap ($3?!?!). Now, after owning it and listening to it, I have a theory--I think Capitol produced a boatload of a low-quality master, realized their mistake too late, and reduced the price to get rid of their stock. I could be wrong--the problems could be inherent in the original tapes, but either way, this release suffers from some serious sound quality issues. A subtle but maddening crackly, buzzy recurring distortion pervades a lot of the album, in the background and accompanying vocals and instruments alike. It's not constant, but it happens enough to drive me nuts, even on the first listen. To make sure it wasn't just my copy, I checked the electronic version on iTunes, and the same problem's there. Assuming that this electronic-sounding problem wasn't part of Merle and the Strangers' sound at the show, it's actually kind of embarrassing that Capitol would release a professional CD with such poor quality. Sorry Capitol, but a disclaimer trying to excuse "imperfections" by talking about "limitations of the recording techniques and equipment of the day" doesn't really cut it--countless albums, 60's and earlier, have been remastered at a much higher quality. If you're not the kind of person who this would bother, or love Merle so much that you think it's still worth owning (this guy included), then please buy it (it's a great concert), but if you think you might be annoyed by subtle but recurring sound quality issues, you may want to check out some other Merle first.
That said, the show recorded on this album is awesome. Merle plays a number of great hits, like the energetic opener "Mama Tried," and a medley of hit singles about drinking and law trouble. The arrangements are similar to the studio albums, but the live energy, Merle's banter and the crowd's energy set the live versions apart. It's one of the most intimate concerts I've heard on recording--you really feel like you're there in small-town Muskogee as the MC introduces Merle, the mayor hands him the key to the city, and the fans cheer when they recognize the songs. The fans sound pleased as punch to be immortalized by Merle's hit song, and they cheer like their lives depend on it.
Other standouts include covers of Jimmie Rodgers (with yodeling), a Buck Owens tune sung by one of the Strangers, a Strangers instrumental, and rare Merle tracks like "White Line Fever" and "Billy Overcame His Size." Listening to this again, I'm so impressed with how tight the Strangers are--the pedal steel and rhythm section cook with gas, and perfectly accompany Merle. By the end, I want to join in the Muskogee standing ovation and beg Merle for more music. If only Capitol had put out a higher quality remaster, this album would be perfect! Because of the flaws, I sadly wouldn't recommend this to a new Merle fan, and would encourage listeners (myself included) to listen past the defects to the great music beneath.
Customer Rating:
Summary: If you only buy one live album in your life, this is the one to have!!
Comment: Only Carlton Hainey could have pulled off this masterpiece of a show. From the opening introduction to the closing bars of Okie From Muskogee, Merle Haggard and his Strangers are on fire. The interplay between Roy Nichols and Norm Hamlet is worthy fodder for a doctoral thesis on how country music is supposed to be played. Listen closely to the subtlety of these two masters and you'll see what I mean. Haggard was certainly at the top of his game when this album came out and in my opinion seldom sounded better. I've seen him live at least three times yet I consider this to be one of his finest vocal efforts.
If I have one complaint it would be that there is a noticeable splice right before White Line Fever. I realize that the album had to be culled and the choicest selections rendered, but Capitol could have done a better editing job. That said if this is all one has to complain about then they're doing good. This album as well as Fightin' Side Of Me are HIGHLY, HIGHLY reccomended.
Customer Rating:
Summary: "Mama Tried" worth the price of admission
Comment: The highlights of this bargain-priced live album are two-fold: Haggard's outstanding songs and the playing of guitarist Roy Nichols. You can hear almost note for note where Jerry Garcia found some of his licks. It's a bit dated, of course, but still a winner.
Customer Rating:
Summary: Great album!
Comment: This album is great.
I would just like to add the previous reviewer Donald mentioned another live album that is just one of my all time favorite live albums. It is called "The Fightin' Side of Me". It is a little tough to find though because it is on a double CD. If you search for "Just Between the Two of Us" you will see "The Fightin'Side of Me" which has "Harold's Super Service", "Medley: Devil Woman, I'm Movin On, Folsom Prison Blues, Jackson, Orange Blossom Special, Love's Gonna Live Here" "T.B.Blues" etc...It is truely an incredible album.
Customer Rating:
Summary: A True Legend!
Comment: One of country music's most beloved performers is Merle Haggard. Merle is one of best from the classic years of country music that didn't have a famous relative to pave his way to stardom. Or be one of the pretty boys of today that have to rely on their looks not their voices.
This Cd is a snapshot of country's most popular performer at his best. The song Okie From Muskogee stayed at #1 for 4 impressive weeks and won single of the year. Other notable hits included Mama Tried, Silver Wings and a medley of his others timeless classics. An instrumental from his band The Strangers called Blue Rock. Billy Over Came His Size was written by Merle for this recording as he was heading to Muskogee. And as he quotes in the CD,"I had a little help writting this tune, with Jim Beam". Hobo Bill's Last Ride is a sad tale of a man that was down on his luck and depended on the rails as a means of travel. With no family or friends to surround him. Hobo Bill's dynasty came to a tragic end. Other notable titles include White Line Fever, Workin' Man Blues and If I Had Left it Up To You. Closing out the CD with The Okie From Muskogee. One of the most honest hard working artist of our time. Merle Haggard deserves a Lifetime Award.
|
